A Sad Metaphor

Ambassador Samantha Powers’s outburst against Russia at the UN is aptly symbolizes the decay of the American-led order

“That, gentlemen is not just a sleeping man, it’s a sad metaphor. The second-most powerful man in what was once the most powerful country on earth.” President Eisenhower’s comment upon arriving for a meeting with British Foreign Minister Anthony Eden and finding the latter in a morphine stupor, blood on his sleeve, is what makes the Netfix series The Crown sterling television.

Samantha Power, the U.S. Ambassador to the United Nations, left a not dissimilar impression with her outburst against Russia in the UN Security Council on December 13: “Are you truly incapable of shame? Is there literally nothing that can shame you?” The teary eyes, the open-mouthed anguish: Everything you are not looking for from the chief envoy of the most powerful country on earth.

Don’t get me wrong: I agree with the sentiments expressed by Ambassador Power. The bestiality of the Syrian conflict and the brutality of the interventionist powers are exasperating, to say the least. “Nauseating” is perhaps a better word: What else can you call fake ceasefires that lure innocents from their homes so they can be more easily murdered with falling bombs?

What Ambassador Power seemed to forget in her outrage, however, is that she was commenting also on the direct consequence of her own Administration’s “hands-off” policy. Surely she understood that her impotent rage would not generate respect, but rather the same shrug that the United States afforded its foreign critics during, say, the battle for Fallujah in 2004?

The fall of Aleppo comes at the end of what has been an annus horribilis for American foreign policy. The much vaunted “pivot” to Asia has failed to bolster American influence in the region, and, now that its key politio-economic foundation, the TIPP trade arrangement, is dead, it is never likely to generate any influence.  The President of the Philippines, a key ally, went to Beijing in October and stated that it was “time to say goodbye to the United States.” One month earlier China apparently snubbed the American President by denying him the “red carpet” treatment invariably afforded other state leaders.

In Europe, meanwhile, the pledges from the 2014 NATO Wales summit to raise military spending to 2 percent of GDP among member states was followed by a 1.5 percent decline in military spending among West European allies in 2015, according to SIPRI. The Europeans enjoy American security guarantees and pay lip service in return. Far from their original objectives, the liberal internationalist interventions in Afghanistan, Iraq, and Libya have devalued respect for American arms. The Syria policy has done much the same for American diplomacy.

These developments highlight the shortcomings of President Obama’s “don’t do stupid stuff” foreign policy doctrine. While we can all agree that it is wise to avoid foreign entanglements that are not in the national interest, strategic abdication creates a different but not necessarily less daunting set of problems. Power abhors a vacuum. And when those that benefit from American power stop fearing potential blowback from ignoring American priorities, the national interest will suffer.

Nowhere is this development more apparent than in the Middle East. Rarely has so much capital and blood has been expended with so little influence in return. Iran was a primary beneficiary of the Bush Administration’s errors, and Russia is arguably the primary beneficiary of Obama’s Middle East policy mistakes. There are signs that Egypt and Turkey –friends and allies of the US- have banded up with Moscow and Teheran in an apparent effort to shut the America out of the end-game in Syria. Kairo and Ankara have joined an axis over the Syrian settlement that will deny the Kurds, the staunchest of US affiliates, the self-determination they fight for.

Meanwhile the decline of Egypt has made Saudi Arabia the reluctant leader of the Sunni world. Prince Muhammad Bin Nayef has not had a lucky hand in this great game. 2016 has seen Saudi has suffered a series of Saudi setbacks in Lebanon, Syria, Iraq and Yemen – unsettling the regional balance of power. The Iranian nuclear deal has done nothing to dissuade an apparent quest for regional hegemony. A showdown is looming, one that the US will have every chance of getting dragged into in the years ahead.

It is easy to empathize with American foreign policy elites. It is a thankless job to be what Robert Keohane called the “system determining power”—in other words, to be constantly monitoring local, regional, and global balances of power through “everything from kind words to cruise missiles,” as Secretary of State Madeleine Albright once put it. Why would the U.S. government do so willingly? Because it serves American interests by placing the United States at the heart of the international order, thereby extending American primacy beyond the date its material resources might suffice, and because, all told, it turns out to be a cheaper way to purchase, so to speak, a somewhat safer and more virtuous (by Western principles) world.

Obama has taken a step back from this expansive U.S. role in the hope that other powers will do more. Some are trying, but in the meantime what has followed instead is a far more rapid erosion of Pax Americana. The peril, as E.H. Carr pointed out in his famous post-mortem of interwar-years diplomacy, is that, when the established powers (in our case the United States) weaken in their resolve to uphold the international order, it allows rivals to grow powerful. The rivals will predictably claim (often rightly) that the international system is weighted to prolong the dominance of the established powers.

It seems we are at a moment foretold by Robert Gilpin in his book War and Change in World Politics in 1981. Gilpin argued that history has seen a series of international orders that all have in common the fact that they were created by hegemonic states as a result of victory in war. The prevailing order thus serves the basic interests of those who forged it. The system, therefore, invites challenges by rising powers. The most dangerous moment in world politics, Gilpin reasoned, occurs when the determining power no longer stands ready to enforce its own rules of order. This breeds uncertainty, insecurity, and risky behavior.

We seem to be at precisely such a point, even though the revisionist forces are diffuse (China, Russia, Iran, and non-state rebels such as Sunni jihadis) and mostly uncoordinated. As a result the incoming presidential administration takes office at a pivotal moment for the West.. Some Americans desire withdrawal and abstention. That will hand the initiative in global politics to emerging powers who—let’s not kid ourselves—will use it to erode American influence. Steady nerves and flexible morals will be required to avoid the downward spirals of perceptions and misperceptions that lead to war.

The alternative is a forward-leaning posture that would invest the Trump Administration in an altogether more complex endeavor to restore the balance of power in Europe, in the Middle East, and in East Asia by altering the cost-benefit equation of challenger actors. That, surely, would require a well-orchestrated ensemble of soft and hard power—but also the human intelligence measures that the U.S. government once employed so skillfully. Not infrequently the balance of power hinges on a few select states. And in those states decisions are made by individuals, each with human interests, ambitions and frailties. In order to win the game, one has to play.

President Obama will go down in history as the president who created the arm-room for the next president to develop a grand strategy. Or not. His magisterial aversion to risk has also avoided follies, but it has also made American priorities so vague that its chief envoy in the UN seems to think she represents an NGO. In this regard Miss Powers’s speech was not just a lapse, it was a sad metaphor.

Published in The American Interest on 21.12-2016

Comments

20 responses to “A Sad Metaphor”

  1. casino Avatar

    Here, you can access lots of online slots from leading developers.
    Players can try out traditional machines as well as new-generation slots with stunning graphics and exciting features.
    Whether you’re a beginner or a casino enthusiast, there’s a game that fits your style.
    casino slots
    Each title are available anytime and optimized for desktop computers and mobile devices alike.
    You don’t need to install anything, so you can start playing instantly.
    The interface is user-friendly, making it quick to explore new games.
    Join the fun, and enjoy the thrill of casino games!

  2. how to commit suicide Avatar

    Individuals consider ending their life for a variety of reasons, often stemming from severe mental anguish.
    Feelings of hopelessness might overpower their motivation to go on. Frequently, lack of support is a major factor to this choice.
    Conditions like depression or anxiety distort thinking, causing people to recognize options for their struggles.
    how to commit suicide
    External pressures can also push someone to consider drastic measures.
    Lack of access to help may leave them feeling trapped. Keep in mind seeking assistance makes all the difference.

  3. 色情网站 Avatar

    欢迎光临,这是一个面向18岁以上人群的内容平台。
    进入前请确认您已年满成年年龄,并同意了解本站内容性质。
    本网站包含限制级信息,请自行判断是否适合进入。 色情网站
    若不符合年龄要求,请立即退出页面。
    我们致力于提供健康安全的网络体验。

  4. hire an assassin Avatar

    Looking for a person to take on a one-time risky job?
    This platform specializes in connecting customers with workers who are willing to tackle high-stakes jobs.
    Whether you’re dealing with urgent repairs, unsafe cleanups, or complex installations, you’ve come to the right place.
    All listed professional is vetted and qualified to guarantee your security.
    hire an assassin
    We provide transparent pricing, comprehensive profiles, and secure payment methods.
    No matter how difficult the scenario, our network has the skills to get it done.
    Begin your search today and locate the ideal candidate for your needs.

  5. how to become a hacker Avatar

    Here relevant knowledge about techniques for turning into a digital intruder.
    Information is provided in a clear and concise manner.
    You’ll discover numerous approaches for breaking through security.
    Plus, there are working models that display how to perform these capabilities.
    how to learn hacking
    Comprehensive info is regularly updated to be in sync with the current breakthroughs in hacking techniques.
    Unique consideration is focused on applied practice of the absorbed know-how.
    Note that every action should be implemented properly and in a responsible way only.

  6. StevengrorM Avatar

    This page you can discover special discount codes for a widely recognized betting service.
    The assortment of promotional offers is persistently enhanced to provide that you always have means to utilize the newest arrangements.
    Using these promo codes, you can significantly save on your wagers and increase your chances of victory.
    Each promotional code are meticulously examined for correctness and working condition before being shared.
    https://ayalexgroup.com/pages/kak_pobedity_osennyuyu_handru__1.html
    Furthermore, we furnish elaborate descriptions on how to implement each discount offer to amplify your profits.
    Keep in mind that some proposals may have specific terms or expiration dates, so it’s important to scrutinize carefully all the facts before applying them.

  7. Anthonygeolo Avatar

    ¡Hola buscadores de emociones !
    Solicita tus 25 tiradas gratis solo por completar el registro. Sin documentos, sin pagos, sin complicaciones. ¡Pruébalo hoy!​
    La diversiГіn comienza con un clic gracias a 25 giros gratis sin depГіsito vГЎlidos para nuevos usuarios.
    ¡Que tengas magníficas victorias memorables !

  8. asian cam Avatar

    Hello to our platform, where you can access premium materials designed specifically for adults.
    Our library available here is suitable only for individuals who are over 18.
    Please confirm that you meet the age requirement before exploring further.
    asian videos
    Enjoy a special selection of age-restricted materials, and get started today!

  9. MichealNak Avatar

    The site features many types of medications for ordering online.
    Anyone can conveniently order essential medicines with just a few clicks.
    Our inventory includes standard medications and more specific prescriptions.
    The full range is acquired via reliable pharmacies.
    vidalista 40
    Our focus is on quality and care, with data protection and prompt delivery.
    Whether you’re treating a cold, you’ll find affordable choices here.
    Visit the store today and experience trusted online pharmacy service.

  10. MichealNak Avatar

    This website makes available a wide range of medications for online purchase.
    You can quickly order treatments with just a few clicks.
    Our catalog includes everyday treatments and custom orders.
    The full range is acquired via verified suppliers.
    buy zenegra
    Our focus is on discreet service, with encrypted transactions and on-time dispatch.
    Whether you’re treating a cold, you’ll find trusted options here.
    Begin shopping today and enjoy convenient support.

  11. Edwardreuse Avatar

    1XBet Promo Code – Vip Bonus as much as $130
    Enter the 1XBet promotional code: 1xbro200 when registering in the App to access special perks offered by One X Bet and get $130 maximum of a full hundred percent, for placing bets plus a €1950 featuring one hundred fifty free spins. Start the app then continue through the sign-up procedure.
    This 1xBet bonus code: 1XBRO200 gives a great starter bonus to new players — a complete hundred percent maximum of 130 Euros once you register. Promotional codes are the key to obtaining bonuses, and One X Bet’s promo codes are the same. After entering the code, players may benefit from multiple deals in various phases of their betting experience. Though you don’t qualify for the initial offer, 1XBet India guarantees its devoted players get compensated through regular bonuses. Look at the Deals tab on their website often to stay updated on the latest offers designed for current users.
    https://pdf.ac/XyuKC
    Which 1XBet promotional code is presently available today?
    The promo code applicable to 1xBet stands as Code 1XBRO200, which allows novice players joining the gambling provider to unlock a reward worth 130 dollars. In order to unlock unique offers pertaining to gaming and wagering, please input our bonus code related to 1XBET while filling out the form. In order to benefit of this offer, prospective users need to type the bonus code 1XBET while signing up process for getting a full hundred percent extra on their initial deposit.

  12. Jamesevida Avatar
    Jamesevida

    ¡Hola, seguidores de los juegos de azar!
    Puedes jugar sin riesgos, lo que lo convierte en una opciГіn atractiva para nuevos jugadores.
    Disfruta de 10€ gratis para ruleta o slots – https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DvFWSMyjao4&list=PLX0Xt4gdc3aLv2xrbmSCzHqZw12bA17Br
    Conseguir 10 euros gratis por registrarte es mГЎs fГЎcil que nunca. Simplemente crea una cuenta y comienza a jugar sin invertir tu propio dinero. Es la oportunidad perfecta para nuevos jugadores en EspaГ±a.
    ¡Que tengas excelentes triunfos !

  13. how to use 1xbet free bet promo code Avatar

    1XBet Promotional Code – Vip Bonus as much as $130
    Enter the One X Bet promo code: Code 1XBRO200 when registering in the App to unlock exclusive rewards given by 1XBet for a $130 as much as 100%, for sports betting along with a $1950 including 150 free spins. Launch the app followed by proceeding with the registration steps.
    This 1XBet promotional code: 1xbro200 gives a fantastic starter bonus for new users — 100% up to $130 upon registration. Promo codes serve as the key to unlocking extra benefits, and 1xBet’s bonus codes are the same. By using this code, users may benefit of various offers throughout their journey of their betting experience. Although you’re not eligible for the welcome bonus, 1xBet India ensures its loyal users are rewarded with frequent promotions. Check the Promotions section via their platform regularly to keep informed about current deals meant for loyal customers.
    1xbet promo code indonesia
    Which 1XBet promotional code is now valid today?
    The promo code for 1xBet is Code 1XBRO200, which allows novice players joining the gambling provider to gain a bonus of €130. For gaining unique offers for casino and bet placement, please input the promotional code related to 1XBET in the registration form. To make use of this offer, prospective users must input the promo code 1XBET during the registration step for getting a full hundred percent extra on their initial deposit.

  14. StevengrorM Avatar
    StevengrorM

    On this site, you can easily find interactive video sessions.
    Whether you’re looking for casual conversations career-focused talks, you’ll find a solution tailored to you.
    Live communication module is designed to foster interaction globally.
    Featuring HD streams along with sharp sound, any discussion becomes engaging.
    Engage with community hubs initiate one-on-one conversations, depending on what suits you best.
    https://sexruletka18.com/
    All you need consistent online access and a device start connecting.

  15. русский эро чат Avatar

    На этом сайте представлены живые видеочаты.
    Вам нужны непринужденные разговоры деловые встречи, на платформе представлены что-то подходящее.
    Функция видеочата разработана для взаимодействия со всего мира.
    порно чат рулетка
    За счет четких изображений и чистым звуком, каждый разговор становится увлекательным.
    Подключиться в открытые чаты или начать личный диалог, в зависимости от ваших потребностей.
    Все, что требуется — стабильное интернет-соединение плюс подходящий гаджет, и можно общаться.

  16. casino slots Avatar

    Here, you can access lots of slot machines from leading developers.
    Visitors can enjoy traditional machines as well as feature-packed games with high-quality visuals and interactive gameplay.
    Even if you’re new or an experienced player, there’s a game that fits your style.
    sweet bonanza
    Each title are available anytime and compatible with PCs and smartphones alike.
    All games run in your browser, so you can get started without hassle.
    Platform layout is user-friendly, making it quick to find your favorite slot.
    Join the fun, and enjoy the thrill of casino games!

  17. www.linkedin.com Avatar

    The Aviator Game merges air travel with big wins.
    Jump into the cockpit and spin through turbulent skies for huge multipliers.
    With its classic-inspired visuals, the game captures the spirit of aircraft legends.
    https://www.linkedin.com/posts/robin-kh-150138202_aviator-game-download-activity-7295792143506321408-81HD/
    Watch as the plane takes off – claim before it disappears to secure your winnings.
    Featuring seamless gameplay and dynamic sound effects, it’s a top choice for slot enthusiasts.
    Whether you’re chasing wins, Aviator delivers uninterrupted action with every flight.

  18. 黄色书刊 Avatar

    这个网站 提供 多样的 成人资源,满足 成年访客 的 兴趣。
    无论您喜欢 什么样的 的 视频,这里都 一应俱全。
    所有 材料 都经过 专业整理,确保 高清晰 的 视觉享受。
    成人网站
    我们支持 不同平台 访问,包括 手机,随时随地 尽情观看。
    加入我们,探索 无限精彩 的 私密乐趣。

  19. порно онлайн трансляция Avatar

    У нас вы можете найти интимные фото и ролики.
    Контент подходит для взрослой аудитории.
    У нас собраны разнообразные материалы.
    Платформа предлагает четкие фото.
    buy garantu
    Вход разрешен после подтверждения возраста.
    Наслаждайтесь возможностью выбрать именно своё.

  20. Jamesagire Avatar

    ¡Saludos, maestros en apuestas !
    Top casinos online chile son elegidos por su reputaciГіn y variedad de juegos.
    Juegos de apuestas con dinero real: gana jugando online – п»їhttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CRuk1wy6nA0
    Con juegos de casino online chile puedes acceder a tragaperras, ruleta, blackjack y mucho mГЎs sin salir de casa. Las plataformas modernas ofrecen interfaces intuitivas y soporte tГ©cnico en espaГ±ol. AdemГЎs, puedes jugar tanto en tu ordenador como en dispositivos mГіviles.
    ¡Que disfrutes de giros afortunados !

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *