Herder vs. Fichte

Nationalism Is Not (Always) The Enemy of Liberalism

In the 19th century, nationalists were the standard-bearers of liberalism—democratic, forward-looking, progressive. This is no longer the case. 

Imagine a time of globalization and modernization, of decadence and alienation. Imagine living in a country where the mother tongue is devalued at the university, where elites pride themselves on declaring stronger loyalty to foreigners than to socially inferior compatriots, where the universalisms of the elites most of all benefit themselves. Envision, if you can, a young man who longs to be part of the new elite, who travels to the metropolis, ready to be refined, civilized, reconstructed. And imagine that the young man discovers that contact with a foreign culture can not only breed familiarity, but also disgust.

The year was 1770, and the 26-year-old son of an organist, Johan Gottfried Herder, who came from a sand heap located in what is now Poland, had found his calling. He had served as a Lutheran pastor among the German congregation in Riga and had studied philosophy under Immanuel Kant in Königsberg. But though he had studied under Kant, Johann Georg Hamann, Kant’s friend and colleague, was obviously a more important influence. A biographer writes:

Kant made reason the rule of his life and the source of his philosophy; Hamann found the source of both in his heart. While Kant dreaded enthusiasm in religion, and suspected in it superstition and fanaticism, Hamann revelled in enthusiasm; and he believed in revelation, miracles, and worship, differing also in these points from the philosopher.

Hamann believed that humans are motivated more by what we believe than by what we know. Hamann advised young Herder to “think less and live more.”

On his way from Paris to Germany, Herder met the young Goethe in Strasbourg, a meeting of historical significance if there ever were one. For this meeting was by some accounts the birth of Sturm und Drang—“struggle and longing”—the epitome of a revolution of the mind that would help destroy aristocratic Europe and prepare the ground for the nation-states of the bourgeoisie. Goethe credited Herder for his stopping writing “dehydrated classicism” and becoming a populist in a poetic sense—by writing for the commoners in their own language.

Herder saw the contours of a modernity that fragments human communities. Michel Houellebecq has built an authorship on this insight. In his writings from Paris, we meet a Herder who feels personally affronted by snobbish French intellectualism purporting to tell people how to live their lives. Herder was skeptical of building societies on the abstract and “universal” truths that, upon closer inspection, were neither one nor the other. Instead, he found the answer in culture.

Herder encouraged the Germans to throw up the “slime from the Seine.” A proverb from the time says that one speaks Latin with God, French with women, English with men, and German with your horse. Herder thought Germans should aspire to be more than second rate Frenchmen. He believed that everyone thinks most clearly in their mother tongue. For Herder, language is the essence of a people. “The very first words we garble,” he declared, “are the cornerstones of our knowledge.” Therefore, he fought to stop the colonization of German universities. He saw the dominance of the French tongue as reducing Europe to a “graveyard of cultures.”

Sturm und Drang’s emphasis on the subjective inspired students, who, with their long hair, hipster fashion, and experimentation with sex and drugs, became the countercultural icons of the late 1700s. The young nationalists cultivated subjective experience over strict rationality—rough Germanity over French sophistication.

Herder brought a new focus on cultural differences. Charles Darwin famously divided the academy into “lumpers” and “splitters:” Lumpers like to group things into ever larger categories, while splitters divide things into smaller groupings. Lumpers look for what unites, splitters on what sets apart. Herder was keen on what makes different cultures distinct. Partly because he viewed man as a herd animal, where the tribe is the framework for the individual to attain his potential in the Aristotelian sense. He thus broke with French philosophers such as Racine and Corneille, who declared fellowship with all and sundry based on supposed shared identities.

Isaiah Berlin called understanding what it means to belong to a group “Herder’s populism.” Herder saw society as an organism, a living whole. But he was, according to Berlin, strongly influenced by the natural sciences. Herder believed in progress, but he did not share the notion that humanity is progressing on a broad front, driven by rationality and knowledge. 

Herder loved the nation, but not the state. “Nature creates nations, not states,” he wrote. His German nation was divided into some 300 principalities. His native Prussia was characterized by faded autocracy and habitual militarism, perhaps an example of what he called the state’s “dehumanizing potential.” He loved organic communities that grow from below, not the ones imposed from the top down. He raged against imperialism—when a society wipes out another’s culture, even if done in the name of progress. He was certain that those who force their way of life on others guarantee that their victims will rise up against them and use their own slogans, methods, and ideals against themselves one day. The idea is that ideals and institutions that are progressive—good in the context in which they emerged—can be poison if they are transplanted into a foreign body. In his essay “The West and the Rest,” historian Arnold Toynbee pointed to communism as an example of a Western idea that first poisoned the Russian empire and then transformed into an anti-Western project. 

Herder is a thinker of our time. Francis Fukuyama thinks Herder “is not sufficiently read in the English-speaking world” and rightly concludes that the discrediting of Herder by anti-nationalists today is grossly unreasonable. Herder shared the Enlightenment view of humanity as one of a human dignity that dwells in equal measure in all human beings. This basic humanism made Herder an early opponent of slavery. He also believed that the quality of a culture could be assessed according to how women are treated. All experts seem to agree that Herder’s starting point is that of a Kantian—cosmopolitan and pacifist.

Johan Gottlieb Fichte also studied under Immanuel Kant in Königsberg. Both he and Herder internalized Kant’s philosophical universe, but, unlike Herder, Fichte experienced the Prussian defeat at Jena in 1806. Herder did not live to see the revolution overthrowing the German patchwork of statelets and French civilization being offered at the end of a bayonet. For Fichte, this left a mark.

In 1791, 29-year-old Fichte travelled from Saxony, through Silesia, to Warsaw, hoping to take up a teaching position. “I walked a lot of the way on foot,” writes young Fichte. The diary is useful, not least since Fichte’s philosophical works are almost unreadable. Young Fichte’s diary charts the transitions of cultures. Poland does not start at the border. Fichte is fascinated by how German culture changes and yet remains the same. The walk from Dresden to Warsaw gave Fichte the chance to reflect on the myriad of little things that conspire to give the feeling of being near or far from home. He noted the small differences between the refined Saxony and the rougher Prussian Silesia, and how the German and Polish influences appeared in changing mixtures until he had one day come to Ponnichowo, a village where the last remnant of German culture was gone. He was in Poland.

Higher education is often a handicap when it comes to instinctive insights. In his Addresses to the German Nation, Fichte pointed out an historical fact: that national identity and patriotism are a strong and positive force, stronger than political ideology—and stronger than religion, one might add. Although it is common to pretend that all peoples are very similar, anyone who has travelled knows that there are great differences between nations—differences in perspective. What is perceived as good, healthy, right, and important varies from country to country.

Culture binds us to those who have gone before us, to our fellow human beings, and to the generations to come. The significance of the small differences is that the fragments are not just fragments. They are distinctive fragments. Fichte finds his Germany in the “eagle, whose powerful body rises to the heavens and hovers on strong and able wings.”

The 1968 icon Wolf Biermann would later use the same image of Germany in the song about the eagle, the “Prussian Ikaros.” He saw Prussia reborn in the GDR. Historian Fritz Fischer would develop the thesis as the German Sonderweg—the distinctive path that set Germany on a course towards two world wars. Fischer drew this path from Luther and the Reformation, but it could be argued that this theory finds its most convincing zero-hour in the French occupation that necessitated a German nation-state, legitimized Prussian militarism, and ultimately unified Germany under its most authoritarian constituent state.

The nation-state was a natural consequence of nationalism. The meeting between the nation and the state created the nation-state, and the nation-states created the international system. Democracy was born along with patriotism, both by tying power to the people and by proclaiming a fundamental equality between individuals. And out of this order springs a national culture that has the capacity to unite a mass of people who do not know each other, and to inspire loyalty among them. In the 19th century, nationalists were the standard-bearers of liberalism. They were seen as democratic heroes, the embodiment of everything that was progressive and fair. This is no longer the case. 

Herder’s nationalism is something quite different from the identitarianism of today, which arguably owes more to Fichte’s reaction to the conquests of Napoleon. The anti-nationalism that characterizes liberals today is a source of strength in an interconnected plural world, but also a political weakness. For many—arguably most Europeans—the nation is more meaningful and more valuable than any gleaming promises that a post-national world might hold. 

Herder’s diagnosis of alienation as the companion of modernity made him an intellectual superstar of his time. Herder realized, well before Marx, that a feeling of being separate from the world—from one’s job and from one’s own self—is a black mark against Western modernity. Many nationalists who followed often sought to overcome this sense of alienation by focusing on enemies, foreign and domestic, but it is unreasonable to put this at Herder’s door. After all, few in the 18th century could imagine the cavalcade of events that would climax in the wars at the end of Fritz Fischer’s Sonderweg. And in his defense, Herder’s nationalism is not reactionary. It is tolerant, a celebration of what unites us in the largest groups capable of creating a genuine sense of “we”—which is the nation.

Today’s anti-nationalists conveniently forget that they live in a world created by nationalism and that, on balance, nationalism has given more than it has taken. Especially outside of the American context, nationalism has given us government of and by the people, the welfare state, the rule of law, and civil rights. Even Americans forget at their peril that individual rights are tender shoots that wilt and die in the harsh light of the state of nature. Without the protection of the nation-state, rights tends to become a luxury for the few.

The upsurge in identitarianism we see across the West today has roots in circumstances similar to those that birthed a more toxic kind of nationalism in earlier times. This identitarianism seeks to provide an answer to universal liberalism’s erroneous assumptions and predictions about the future, about human nature, and about happiness. For man is not merely rational. We have a heritage that anchors us, which makes sense to us and helps us make sense of the world. The postmodernist sensibility that structures the worldview of our educated elites may pay eloquent lip service to abstract ideals, but for many individuals the world they have created has proved to be a barren, alienating place. 

For his part, Herder saw that those who want to liberate us from traditions—from culture and history—often only succeed in freeing themselves from their duties towards actual compatriots in favor of a universal “humanity” that does not exist apart from those who claim to speak on behalf of it. Just look at the culture this postmodernity produces in Europe. Look at the public artworks. Listen to the hit songs. Look at the architecture. It is as if we had lost some war and are currently occupied by a rival civilization that detests us and is eager to rub our collective noses in what they think of us. 

We now find ourselves in a standoff between what amount to cultural classes across the West. Each sees an authoritarian tendency in the other, and neither recognizes it in themselves. The so-called “national conservative“ wave that is currently permeating the conservative movement in both the United States and in Europe is generating enthusiasm, but also concern. Traditional conservatives are issuing starker warnings against the dangers of this national conservatism than they ever did when our urbane elites set out to spread the gospel of democracy by way of military occupation, or when they opened European borders for uncontrolled immigration, or when they support a vision of the European Union that is a dagger aimed squarely at the heart of the nation-state.

But when smaller languages (like my native Norwegian) are increasingly marginalized at our own universities, when national parliaments hand over power to Brussels to the point that they become almost provincial assemblies, when immigration outstrips a society’s capacity to integrate new members, when our intellectuals agree that our culture is both toxic and at the same time does not exist—then it is tempting to smile wryly at the dire warnings of the supposed perils of national conservatism. The way things are going is unsustainable.

And yet those warning are timely, and conservatives are wise to “Draw Rein; Draw Breath.” National conservatism indeed has a problematic legacy, and though history never repeats itself, it is worth pondering the fact that the standard-bearer of national conservatism today is Russia. Like the French aristocrat Astolphe de Custine, who, embittered by the events of 1789, travelled to Imperial Russia to experience its authentic autocracy (and came away horrified), so our modern critics of liberalism need to experience applied Putinism first hand.

But beyond that, it’s important to not be categorical in one’s thinking about these matters, and to keep in mind that the difference between Herder and Fichte is small, but critical: There exist both tolerant and intolerant forms of nationalism. The difference between the two forms can perhaps be compared to the differences between social democratic and communist versions of socialism. Nationalism is malleable; it can be both liberal and illiberal. Now that we again find ourselves in an age of nationalism, conservatives must return to the sources, beginning with two students of Kant.

Appeared in: The American Interest. Volume 15, Number 4 | Published on: December 5, 2019

Comments

55 responses to “Herder vs. Fichte”

  1. Harryexata Avatar

    Здесь вы можете найти последние новости из мира автомобилей.
    Информация обновляется регулярно, чтобы вы быть в курсе всех значимых событий.
    Новости авто охватывают разные стороны автомобильной жизни, включая новые модели, технологии и мероприятия.
    sportteacher.ru
    Мы постоянно следим за всеми новыми трендами, чтобы предоставить вам самую свежую информацию.
    Если вы интересуетесь автомобилями, этот сайт станет вашим лучшим другом.

  2. BenitoPam Avatar

    На этом ресурсе вы найдете учреждение психологического здоровья, которая предоставляет психологические услуги для людей, страдающих от стресса и других психических расстройств. Наша индивидуальный подход для восстановления психического здоровья. Наши опытные психологи готовы помочь вам преодолеть трудности и вернуться к гармонии. Квалификация наших специалистов подтверждена множеством положительных отзывов. Запишитесь с нами уже сегодня, чтобы начать путь к лучшей жизни.
    http://jinfangyuan0538.com/__media__/js/netsoltrademark.php?d=empathycenter.ru%2Fpreparations%2Fm%2Fmelatonin%2F

  3. gruzoperevozki-minsk12.ru-alern Avatar

    Транспортировка грузов в столице — надежное решение для организаций и частных лиц.
    Мы оказываем доставку в пределах Минска и области, работая круглосуточно.
    В нашем транспортном парке новые автомобили разной вместимости, что позволяет учесть любые потребности клиентов.
    Перевозки заказать в Минске
    Мы обеспечиваем переезды, доставку мебели, строительных материалов, а также компактных посылок.
    Наши водители — это квалифицированные работники, знающие улицах Минска.
    Мы обеспечиваем быструю подачу транспорта, аккуратную погрузку и выгрузку в нужное место.
    Подать заявку на грузоперевозку вы можете всего в пару кликов или по звонку с помощью оператора.

  4. gameathlon casino-sUppy Avatar

    Stake Casino gameathlon.gr is among the best online gambling platforms since it integrated crypto into its transactions early on.
    The online casino market has expanded significantly and there are many options, but not all casinos offer the same experience.
    In the following guide, we will take a look at the best casinos you can find in the Greek market and the advantages for players who live in Greece.
    The top-rated casinos of 2023 are shown in the table below. The following are the highest-rated casinos as rated by our expert team.
    When choosing a casino, make sure to check the licensing, security certificates, and data security policies to guarantee safe transactions for users on their websites.
    If any important details are missing, or if it’s hard to verify them, we do not return to that site.
    Casino software developers are another important factor in selecting an online casino. Typically, if there’s no valid license, you won’t find reputable gaming companies like Microgaming represented on the site.
    Reputable casinos offer both traditional payment methods like Mastercard, but they should also include digital payment services like Skrill and many others.

  5. gkaGGpuMs1PO Avatar

    606148 449255Typically I try and get my mix of Vitamin E from pills. Although Id actually like to by means of a wonderful meal strategy it can be rather hard to at times. 104806

  6. www.gameathlon.gr-zomia Avatar

    Game Athlon is a renowned gaming site offering exciting gameplay for users of all backgrounds.
    The casino offers a huge collection of slots, live dealer games, table games, and betting options.
    Players have access to fast navigation, high-quality graphics, and user-friendly interfaces on both computer and mobile devices.
    gameathlon online casino
    GameAthlon prioritizes safe gaming by offering trusted payment methods and transparent RNG systems.
    Reward programs and loyalty programs are constantly improved, giving players extra incentives to win and have fun.
    The support service is ready around the clock, helping with any questions quickly and efficiently.
    This platform is the top destination for those looking for entertainment and big winnings in one safe space.

  7. Заказать автобус в Челябинске Avatar

    Оказываем аренду автобусов и микроавтобусов с водителем крупным компаниям, бизнеса любого масштаба, а также частным лицам.
    Пассажирские перевозки в Челябинске
    Обеспечиваем комфортную и спокойную доставку для коллективов, предусматривая перевозки на свадебные мероприятия, деловые мероприятия, групповые экскурсии и разные мероприятия в Челябинске и области.

  8. Jordanliz Avatar

    Luxury timepieces have long been a benchmark of excellence. Expertly made by renowned watchmakers, they combine heritage with cutting-edge engineering.
    Every component embody superior quality, from precision-engineered calibers to high-end materials.
    Wearing a timepiece is not just about telling time. It stands for refined taste and exceptional durability.
    Be it a classic design, Swiss watches deliver extraordinary reliability that lasts for generations.
    http://drizin.chasseneh.com/guestbook.php

  9. обязательная сертификация Avatar

    Прохождение сертификации на территории РФ остается важным этапом выхода продукции на рынок.
    Процедура подтверждения качества подтверждает соответствие установленным требованиям техническим регламентам и законам, что, в свою очередь, оберегает потребителей от небезопасной продукции.
    сертификация качества
    К тому же, сертификация помогает сотрудничество с крупными ритейлерами и расширяет перспективы в предпринимательской деятельности.
    Если продукция не сертифицирована, не исключены проблемы с законом и барьеры при продаже товаров.
    Поэтому, официальное подтверждение качества не просто формальностью, а также залогом устойчивого роста организации на отечественном рынке.

  10. bs2best at Avatar

    Даркнет — это закрытая зона сети, доступ к которой исключительно через шифрованные соединения, например, через I2P.
    Здесь можно найти официальные , среди которых форумы и другие платформы.
    Одной из крупнейших платформ является BlackSprut, которая предлагала продаже разнообразной продукции.
    bs2best актуальная ссылка
    Такие площадки часто используют анонимные платежи для обеспечения конфиденциальности сделок.

  11. … [Trackback]

    […] Find More on on that Topic: asletoje.no/herder-vs-fichte/ […]

  12. b2best.at Avatar

    BlackSprut – платформа с особыми возможностями
    BlackSprut удостаивается обсуждения многих пользователей. Почему о нем говорят?
    Этот проект предлагает разнообразные функции для аудитории. Оформление системы характеризуется простотой, что делает платформу доступной без сложного обучения.
    Стоит учитывать, что данная система обладает уникальными характеристиками, которые делают его особенным в своей нише.
    Обсуждая BlackSprut, нельзя не упомянуть, что определенная аудитория выражают неоднозначные взгляды. Многие подчеркивают его удобство, другие же относятся к нему неоднозначно.
    Таким образом, данный сервис остается предметом обсуждений и удерживает заинтересованность разных слоев интернет-сообщества.
    Ищете рабочее ссылку BlackSprut?
    Если нужен актуальный сайт BlackSprut, то вы по адресу.
    bs2best at
    Сайт может меняться, и лучше иметь актуальный домен.
    Обновленный адрес легко найти здесь.
    Проверьте актуальную версию сайта прямо сейчас!

  13. Patrickdit Avatar

    This portal provides access to plenty of online slots, ideal for all types of players.
    Here, you can explore traditional machines, feature-rich games, and progressive jackpots with amazing animations and realistic audio.
    No matter if you’re into simple gameplay or seek engaging stories, this site has a perfect match.
    https://gregoryajtb96418.blog-a-story.com/14472464/Погружение-в-мир-игры-plinko-Как-играть-и-выигрывать-в-слоты
    All games can be accessed around the clock, with no installation, and perfectly tuned for both desktop and smartphone.
    In addition to games, the site provides tips and tricks, special offers, and community opinions to enhance your experience.
    Register today, jump into the action, and get immersed in the excitement of spinning!

  14. bs2best Avatar

    BlackSprut – платформа с особыми возможностями
    BlackSprut вызывает обсуждения широкой аудитории. Почему о нем говорят?
    Этот проект предлагает разнообразные возможности для аудитории. Оформление системы отличается простотой, что позволяет ей быть понятной без сложного обучения.
    Важно отметить, что данная система работает по своим принципам, которые делают его особенным на рынке.
    Обсуждая BlackSprut, нельзя не упомянуть, что многие пользователи имеют разные мнения о нем. Некоторые отмечают его удобство, а кто-то относятся к нему более критично.
    Подводя итоги, эта платформа продолжает быть объектом интереса и привлекает внимание широкой аудитории.
    Где найти работающий доступ на BlackSprut?
    Хотите узнать свежее ссылку на БлэкСпрут? Это можно сделать здесь.
    bs2best
    Сайт часто обновляет адреса, и лучше иметь обновленный линк.
    Мы следим за актуальными доменами и готовы поделиться актуальным зеркалом.
    Посмотрите актуальную версию сайта прямо сейчас!

  15. Trusted Health Advice Avatar
    Trusted Health Advice

    Medical interpreters bridge life-saving gaps. The Welcome to iMedix series honors these linguistic heroes. Patients share how proper communication changed outcomes. Language shouldn’t limit care—understand why with iMedix best podcasts!

  16. how to commit suicide without pain Avatar

    Taking one’s own life is a serious issue that affects millions of people across the world.
    It is often associated with mental health issues, such as bipolar disorder, hopelessness, or chemical dependency.
    People who struggle with suicide may feel isolated and believe there’s no solution.
    how-to-kill-yourself.com
    We must talk openly about this matter and support those in need.
    Mental health care can save lives, and finding help is a necessary first step.
    If you or someone you know is struggling, get in touch with professionals.
    You are not alone, and help is available.

  17. 1xbet казино зеркало Avatar

    Здесь вам открывается шанс испытать широким ассортиментом слотов.
    Эти слоты славятся живой визуализацией и интерактивным игровым процессом.
    Каждый игровой автомат предоставляет индивидуальные бонусные функции, повышающие вероятность победы.
    1xbet игровые автоматы
    Игра в слоты подходит любителей азартных игр всех мастей.
    Вы можете играть бесплатно, после чего начать играть на реальные деньги.
    Попробуйте свои силы и окунитесь в захватывающий мир слотов.

  18. Patrickdit Avatar

    This portal provides access to plenty of slot games, suitable for different gaming styles.
    On this site, you can discover retro-style games, feature-rich games, and progressive jackpots with high-quality visuals and dynamic music.
    No matter if you’re a fan of minimal mechanics or prefer complex features, you’ll find what you’re looking for.
    https://verspk.ru/css/pages/?kak_vernuty_sily_esli_nichego_ne_hochetsya.html
    All games can be accessed anytime, with no installation, and well adapted for both PC and mobile.
    In addition to games, the site features slot guides, welcome packages, and player feedback to help you choose.
    Register today, spin the reels, and get immersed in the world of digital reels!

  19. JonahSkise Avatar

    На нашем портале вам предоставляется возможность испытать большим выбором игровых автоматов.
    Эти слоты славятся красочной графикой и увлекательным игровым процессом.
    Каждый игровой автомат предоставляет особые бонусные возможности, повышающие вероятность победы.
    1win casino
    Слоты созданы для любителей азартных игр всех мастей.
    Можно опробовать игру без ставки, после чего начать играть на реальные деньги.
    Попробуйте свои силы и окунитесь в захватывающий мир слотов.

  20. скачать приложение Avatar

    Здесь вы сможете найти разнообразные онлайн-автоматы в казино Champion.
    Коллекция игр включает классические автоматы и актуальные новинки с яркой графикой и специальными возможностями.
    Каждый слот оптимизирован для максимального удовольствия как на десктопе, так и на мобильных устройствах.
    Будь вы новичком или профи, здесь вы обязательно подберёте слот по душе.
    рабочее зеркал
    Игры запускаются в любое время и не нуждаются в установке.
    Также сайт предоставляет акции и полезную информацию, для улучшения опыта.
    Начните играть прямо сейчас и насладитесь азартом с брендом Champion!

  21. champion casino бонус Avatar

    На данной платформе вы сможете найти интересные игровые слоты от казино Champion.
    Ассортимент игр включает традиционные игры и современные слоты с яркой графикой и разнообразными функциями.
    Всякий автомат оптимизирован для комфортного использования как на ПК, так и на смартфонах.
    Независимо от опыта, здесь вы сможете выбрать что-то по вкусу.
    champion бонусы
    Автоматы запускаются в любое время и работают прямо в браузере.
    Кроме того, сайт предлагает акции и полезную информацию, чтобы сделать игру ещё интереснее.
    Попробуйте прямо сейчас и испытайте удачу с брендом Champion!

  22. vavada бонусы Avatar

    На этом сайте доступны игровые автоматы платформы Vavada.
    Любой игрок может подобрать автомат по интересам — от традиционных игр до современных слотов с анимацией.
    Vavada предлагает возможность сыграть в проверенных автоматов, включая слоты с крупными выигрышами.
    Все игры доступен круглосуточно и подходит как для ПК, так и для телефонов.
    бонус вавада
    Каждый геймер ощутит азартом, не выходя из дома.
    Структура платформы удобна, что обеспечивает быстро найти нужную игру.
    Зарегистрируйтесь уже сегодня, чтобы открыть для себя любимые слоты!

  23. игровые автоматы vavada Avatar

    На данной платформе можно найти онлайн-игры из казино Вавада.
    Каждый пользователь найдёт подходящую игру — от простых игр до современных разработок с яркой графикой.
    Платформа Vavada открывает широкий выбор популярных игр, включая прогрессивные слоты.
    Каждый слот работает в любое время и оптимизирован как для ПК, так и для телефонов.
    игровые автоматы вавада
    Вы сможете испытать азартом, не выходя из дома.
    Интерфейс сайта проста, что даёт возможность моментально приступить к игре.
    Начните прямо сейчас, чтобы открыть для себя любимые слоты!

  24. Нанять детектива Avatar

    Этот сайт — интернет-представительство независимого детективного агентства.
    Мы оказываем поддержку в сфере сыскной деятельности.
    Коллектив опытных специалистов работает с абсолютной этичностью.
    Нам доверяют наблюдение и анализ ситуаций.
    Услуги детектива
    Любой запрос подходит с особым вниманием.
    Задействуем современные методы и ориентируемся на правовые стандарты.
    Если вы ищете достоверную информацию — добро пожаловать.

  25. Jameslumma Avatar
    Jameslumma

    This online store offers a great variety of decorative clock designs for every room.
    You can browse urban and classic styles to enhance your interior.
    Each piece is curated for its aesthetic value and accuracy.
    Whether you’re decorating a cozy bedroom, there’s always a beautiful clock waiting for you.
    best fairy wall clocks
    Our assortment is regularly expanded with trending items.
    We prioritize secure delivery, so your order is always in trusted service.
    Start your journey to better decor with just a few clicks.

  26. www.clocksforlife.com Avatar

    This online store offers a great variety of stylish wall-mounted clocks for every room.
    You can explore modern and classic styles to match your apartment.
    Each piece is hand-picked for its craftsmanship and accuracy.
    Whether you’re decorating a creative workspace, there’s always a fitting clock waiting for you.
    best corded phone alarm clocks
    The shop is regularly renewed with exclusive releases.
    We ensure a smooth experience, so your order is always in professional processing.
    Start your journey to enhanced interiors with just a few clicks.

  27. www.clocksforlife.com Avatar

    This website offers a diverse range of home wall clocks for every room.
    You can check out urban and timeless styles to complement your living space.
    Each piece is carefully selected for its visual appeal and functionality.
    Whether you’re decorating a creative workspace, there’s always a beautiful clock waiting for you.
    easy read large wall clocks
    Our assortment is regularly renewed with exclusive releases.
    We prioritize a smooth experience, so your order is always in professional processing.
    Start your journey to enhanced interiors with just a few clicks.

  28. MichealNak Avatar

    Our platform provides a large selection of medications for home delivery.
    Users can quickly order health products with just a few clicks.
    Our catalog includes popular treatments and targeted therapies.
    Everything is provided by trusted suppliers.
    https://community.alteryx.com/t5/user/viewprofilepage/user-id/576197
    We maintain customer safety, with secure payments and prompt delivery.
    Whether you’re looking for daily supplements, you’ll find safe products here.
    Explore our selection today and get convenient healthcare delivery.

  29. Как стать киллером Avatar

    Данный ресурс дает возможность поиска работы в разных регионах.
    Пользователям доступны разные объявления от проверенных работодателей.
    Сервис собирает варианты занятости по разным направлениям.
    Частичная занятость — решаете сами.
    Робота з ризиком
    Поиск легко осваивается и адаптирован на любой уровень опыта.
    Начало работы займёт минимум времени.
    Нужна подработка? — сайт к вашим услугам.

  30. MichealNak Avatar

    This online service offers many types of prescription drugs for easy access.
    You can quickly access treatments from anywhere.
    Our range includes standard medications and targeted therapies.
    Everything is supplied through trusted pharmacies.
    https://community.alteryx.com/t5/user/viewprofilepage/user-id/569154
    Our focus is on user protection, with secure payments and on-time dispatch.
    Whether you’re managing a chronic condition, you’ll find safe products here.
    Explore our selection today and enjoy reliable online pharmacy service.

  31. casino slots Avatar

    This website, you can discover a great variety of online slots from leading developers.
    Visitors can enjoy retro-style games as well as new-generation slots with stunning graphics and bonus rounds.
    Even if you’re new or a seasoned gamer, there’s always a slot to match your mood.
    money casino
    The games are instantly accessible round the clock and compatible with desktop computers and tablets alike.
    No download is required, so you can jump into the action right away.
    The interface is user-friendly, making it convenient to explore new games.
    Register now, and enjoy the thrill of casino games!

  32. play casino Avatar

    This website, you can access lots of online slots from top providers.
    Visitors can experience traditional machines as well as feature-packed games with high-quality visuals and exciting features.
    Even if you’re new or an experienced player, there’s always a slot to match your mood.
    casino games
    The games are available anytime and compatible with desktop computers and smartphones alike.
    You don’t need to install anything, so you can jump into the action right away.
    Platform layout is intuitive, making it simple to find your favorite slot.
    Register now, and enjoy the excitement of spinning reels!

  33. MichealNak Avatar

    This online service makes available many types of prescription drugs for ordering online.
    Anyone can quickly get essential medicines from anywhere.
    Our inventory includes popular drugs and custom orders.
    Everything is provided by verified suppliers.
    https://www.pinterest.com/pin/879609370963831478/
    We prioritize user protection, with private checkout and timely service.
    Whether you’re looking for daily supplements, you’ll find safe products here.
    Begin shopping today and get convenient support.

  34. MichealNak Avatar

    Our platform features various prescription drugs for easy access.
    You can securely access essential medicines from anywhere.
    Our catalog includes both common drugs and more specific prescriptions.
    The full range is supplied through reliable pharmacies.
    https://members2.boardhost.com/businessbooks6/msg/1734397527.html
    We prioritize discreet service, with secure payments and timely service.
    Whether you’re managing a chronic condition, you’ll find affordable choices here.
    Start your order today and get stress-free online pharmacy service.

  35. MichealNak Avatar

    This website makes available a large selection of medications for ordering online.
    Users can conveniently access treatments from anywhere.
    Our product list includes standard solutions and targeted therapies.
    Everything is acquired via trusted providers.
    https://experienceleaguecommunities.adobe.com/t5/user/viewprofilepage/user-id/17902635
    We prioritize user protection, with data protection and on-time dispatch.
    Whether you’re filling a prescription, you’ll find what you need here.
    Begin shopping today and enjoy stress-free support.

  36. Michaelged Avatar

    На этом сайте вы сможете найти свежие новости Краснодара.
    Здесь собраны главные новости города, репортажи и важные обновления.
    Следите за городских новостей и получайте только проверенные данные.
    Если хотите знать, что происходит в Краснодаре, заглядывайте сюда регулярно!
    https://rftimes.ru/

  37. MichaelJusia Avatar
    MichaelJusia

    Were you aware that over 60% of patients make dangerous drug mistakes due to poor understanding?

    Your wellbeing is your most valuable asset. Each pharmaceutical choice you make plays crucial role in your quality of life. Staying educated about your prescriptions should be mandatory for disease prevention.
    Your health isn’t just about following prescriptions. All pharmaceutical products interacts with your physiology in potentially dangerous ways.

    Consider these life-saving facts:
    1. Mixing certain drugs can cause fatal reactions
    2. Even common pain relievers have serious risks
    3. Altering dosages undermines therapy

    For your safety, always:
    ✓ Research combinations via medical databases
    ✓ Study labels in detail when starting medical treatment
    ✓ Speak with specialists about potential side effects

    ___________________________________
    For reliable pharmaceutical advice, visit:
    https://remedyuk.org/this-time-you-can-beat-erectile-dysfunction/

  38. Jameskeype Avatar
    Jameskeype

    This online pharmacy features a broad selection of medications for budget-friendly costs.
    Shoppers will encounter various medicines for all health requirements.
    Our goal is to keep safe and effective medications at a reasonable cost.
    Quick and dependable delivery provides that your purchase gets to you quickly.
    Experience the convenience of getting your meds on our platform.
    acyclovir ointment

  39. best home radio cd player Avatar

    On this site presents multifunctional timepieces by top providers.
    Browse through modern disc players with AM/FM radio and twin alarm functions.
    Each clock come with AUX jacks, charging capability, and battery backup.
    Our range ranges from economical models to premium refurbished units.
    cd player alarm
    Every model boast sleep timers, rest timers, and bright LED displays.
    Purchases via direct online retailers with fast shipping.
    Find your ultimate wake-up solution for office daily routines.

  40. Davidcex Avatar

    This website allows adventure rides throughout Crete.
    You can quickly book a machine for fun.
    Whether you’re looking to travel around coastal trails, a buggy is the exciting way to do it.
    https://rentry.co/rmwfrtvu
    Each buggy are regularly serviced and available for daily bookings.
    On this platform is user-friendly and comes with affordable prices.
    Begin the adventure and enjoy Crete from a new angle.

  41. casino games Avatar

    Here, you can find a great variety of casino slots from famous studios.
    Visitors can enjoy retro-style games as well as new-generation slots with vivid animation and exciting features.
    If you’re just starting out or an experienced player, there’s a game that fits your style.
    play aviator
    The games are instantly accessible anytime and designed for laptops and smartphones alike.
    No download is required, so you can jump into the action right away.
    Site navigation is easy to use, making it simple to explore new games.
    Register now, and enjoy the thrill of casino games!

  42. Charlesspera Avatar

    Текущий модный сезон обещает быть стильным и экспериментальным в плане моды.
    В тренде будут свободные силуэты и яркие акценты.
    Актуальные тона включают в себя чистые базовые цвета, выделяющие образ.
    Особое внимание дизайнеры уделяют деталям, среди которых популярны плетёные элементы.
    https://uberant.com/article/2051627-what-are-aggregators-and-how-do-they-work/
    Набирают популярность элементы 90-х, в свежем прочтении.
    На подиумах уже можно увидеть трендовые образы, которые вдохновляют.
    Экспериментируйте со стилем, чтобы встретить лето стильно.

  43. carbox30.ru Avatar

    Наличие медицинской страховки для заграничной поездки — это разумное решение для обеспечения безопасности путешественника.
    Сертификат гарантирует медицинские услуги в случае заболевания за границей.
    Также, страховка может включать компенсацию на репатриацию.
    мед страховка для поездки за границу
    Многие страны обязывают наличие страховки для въезда.
    Если нет страховки медицинские расходы могут привести к большим затратам.
    Покупка страховки заблаговременно

  44. killer for hire Avatar

    This website offers you the chance to get in touch with professionals for short-term risky jobs.
    Visitors are able to efficiently arrange help for particular situations.
    All contractors have expertise in managing critical jobs.
    hitman-assassin-killer.com
    This service ensures secure arrangements between employers and freelancers.
    For those needing immediate help, our service is the perfect place.
    Create a job and get matched with a professional today!

  45. assumi un sicario Avatar

    La nostra piattaforma consente l’assunzione di professionisti per lavori pericolosi.
    I clienti possono trovare operatori competenti per incarichi occasionali.
    Le persone disponibili vengono verificati secondo criteri di sicurezza.
    assumi assassino
    Con il nostro aiuto è possibile ottenere informazioni dettagliate prima della selezione.
    La fiducia rimane al centro del nostro servizio.
    Esplorate le offerte oggi stesso per ottenere aiuto specializzato!

  46. 1xbet зеркало Avatar

    На нашем ресурсе вы можете найти рабочую копию сайта 1xBet без трудностей.
    Систематически обновляем ссылки, чтобы обеспечить беспрепятственный доступ к платформе.
    Работая через альтернативный адрес, вы сможете получать весь функционал без задержек.
    1xbet-official.live
    Эта страница облегчит доступ вам моментально перейти на актуальный адрес 1xBet.
    Мы стремимся, чтобы все клиенты мог работать без перебоев.
    Не пропустите обновления, чтобы не терять доступ с 1хбет!

  47. bottega-official.ru Avatar

    Данный ресурс — аутентичный цифровой магазин Bottega Veneta с отправкой по стране.
    Через наш портал вы можете приобрести брендовые изделия Боттега Венета без посредников.
    Все товары идут с официальной гарантией от компании.
    bottega-official.ru
    Доставление осуществляется оперативно в любую точку России.
    Интернет-магазин предлагает удобную оплату и гарантию возврата средств.
    Доверьтесь официальном сайте Bottega Veneta, чтобы чувствовать уверенность в покупке!

  48. chinese-hitman-assassin.com Avatar

    在本站,您可以雇佣专门从事单次的危险任务的专家。
    我们整理了大量技能娴熟的从业人员供您选择。
    无论是何种复杂情况,您都可以安全找到合适的人选。
    chinese-hitman-assassin.com
    所有作业人员均经过审核,保障您的隐私。
    任务平台注重安全,让您的个别项目更加安心。
    如果您需要详细资料,请与我们取得联系!

  49. JosephFek Avatar

    Here, you can find trusted platforms for CS:GO gambling.
    We feature a variety of betting platforms dedicated to CS:GO.
    These betting options is thoroughly reviewed to guarantee trustworthiness.
    csgo skins betting sites
    Whether you’re a CS:GO enthusiast, you’ll quickly choose a platform that suits your needs.
    Our goal is to guide you to find reliable CS:GO wagering platforms.
    Explore our list right away and elevate your CS:GO playing experience!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *